MrMessiah made BetterLight, an early Minecraft mod that changed how lighting and grass looked. The Minecraft Wiki says features from it later made their way into the game, and that Mojang gave him this cape to say thanks.
The cape was discussed back in 2011 but wasn't granted until 2015, and the exact date isn't known. Who drew it isn't recorded either. MrMessiah himself guessed it might have been Jeb.
Design
A black spade on a pale panel, edged with green and pink.